A book is a way to see the world from a new point of view,
whether it’s the author' or a characters' point of view. I agree with Joe Meno
in that a book is a place and it isn’t always about what form it's in, but the
story itself. Each book is like a fingerprint, no two are exactly the same. Books offer different worlds, characters,
real-life stories, and allow us to explore our imagination, which is what makes
them so unique. I do think some electronic books are missing something, but not
all of them. If the book is a work of art, a complex fingerprint, the hard copy
is needed, and adds to the book as a whole. Something about holding a book and
feeling, smelling and reading the pages of an amazing book adds to the whole
experience of reading, as opposed to reading it electronically. Some stories
though are just as good electronically as in hard cover; it’s when the book is
special to you, personally, that the hard copy is the more magical of the two.
With this said I don't exactly agree with Tom Piazza who made his point clear
on how much he detests electronic books. He says "it's an anti-world. The
computer's ambition is to transcend point of view completely." I disagree
with this comment because of the fact that I have had personal experience with
e-books, I own a Nook, and I still find books and stories enjoyable. The
electronic world is not an "anti-world" it's a whole world all in its
own. It is a very different world, and at first it is hard to get used to, but
it's where the real world is heading and there's nothing anybody can do to stop
it. I do believe we should still keep and make physical copies of books, but I
think eventually, everything will be electronic. The electronic world is
something everybody, including books, will have to get used to.
I think fingerprints is a great analogy to describe the uniqueness of each reading experience. You bring up good points against Piazza. I've also read some books digitally and I agree that you can still enter into the book's world and find it enjoyable.
ReplyDelete